The Calcium Lie

By Robert Thompson and Kathleen Barnes – Unbekoming Book Summary

Aug 06, 2024

Create a square image in the style of an oil painting, focusing on the concept of the sodium/potassium membrane electrical potential (S/PMEP) and its importance for cellular function and health. The image should visually depict the balance of sodium and potassium ions across cell membranes, highlighting the disruption caused by excess calcium and resulting mineral imbalances. Use abstract representations to show the flow of nutrients like glucose and amino acids into cells, and illustrate the impaired function caused by disrupted S/PMEP. Ensure the image is free of any text or words, capturing the concept purely through visual elements.

I covered the excess calcium problem when interviewing Dr Thomas Levy. He’s written extensively on the subject.

Interview with Dr Thomas Levy - Lies are Unbekoming (substack.com)

Could you discuss calcium's role in contributing to chronic diseases like heart disease and cancer?
The link between calcium and chronic diseases like heart disease and cancer ties back to our initial discussion about what causes all diseases: increased numbers of oxidized biomolecules inside the cell. This condition is always accompanied by increased calcium levels, which is why excess calcium intake promotes all diseases. This is a universal condition present in every cell.
A relevant example is the coronary artery calcium score test. This test measures the deposits of calcium in the coronary arteries of the heart and was originally designed to assess the risk of heart attacks. The rationale is straightforward: the more calcium in your blood vessels, the higher the likelihood of blockages and, consequently, heart attacks. The calcium score is categorized as zero, 50, 100, or up to 500, with higher scores indicating greater risk.
However, it has since been recognized that the coronary artery calcium score is also an excellent indicator of all-cause mortality. A high score doesn't just signify the risk of heart attacks but also indicates elevated calcium levels throughout the body, correlating with an increased risk of dying from any cause. Any factor that negatively affects the physiology of all cells will impact all diseases, and calcium is a prime example of this.
This is why appropriate magnesium supplementation is so crucial. Magnesium directly reduces calcium levels and prevents calcium from entering cells in the first place. By managing calcium levels through magnesium intake, the risk associated with high cellular calcium can be mitigated.
Magnesium supplementation plays a crucial role in decreasing all-cause mortality, primarily because it acts as an antithesis to the accumulation of calcium in cellular metabolism. This relationship is particularly evident in the function of calcium channels. Calcium channels are proteins that span the cell membrane, allowing calcium to enter the cell. Normally, magnesium levels are high inside the cell and low outside, while calcium levels are low inside and high outside. However, even though these levels are relative, it doesn't mean that calcium levels can't be elevated within the cell.
Calcium channel proteins facilitate the entry of calcium into cells, and magnesium directly blocks this process. Magnesium acts as a calcium channel blocker, a function similar to certain prescription drugs used for high blood pressure, such as verapamil, diltiazem, and nifedipine. These drugs are used because high levels of calcium cause muscular constriction, leading to increased blood pressure.
Therefore, magnesium's ability to counter the accumulation of calcium inside the cell and prevent it from rising further is, in my opinion, its most important function. This function is vital for health and longevity, based on extensive research I've conducted. Magnesium's effectiveness in blocking calcium channels and regulating calcium levels inside the cell is a key factor in its ability to decrease the risk of various diseases and contribute to overall mortality reduction.

I recently came across this book and thought it worthwhile diving a bit deeper into the subject.

The Calcium Lie

What your doctor still doesn’t know

By Robert Thompson and Kathleen Barnes

The Calcium Lie II: What Your Doctor... book by Robert Thompson (thriftbooks.com)

Questions & Answers

Question 1: What is the central lie that the book "The Calcium Lie II" seeks to expose, and why is it considered dangerous?

The central lie exposed in "The Calcium Lie II" is the widespread belief that calcium is the key to strong bones and that consuming large amounts of calcium through supplements and calcium-rich foods is necessary for maintaining bone health. The authors argue that this misconception is not only incorrect but also dangerous, as excess calcium in the body can lead to numerous health problems, including osteoporosis, osteoarthritis, kidney stones, and arterial plaque.

Interview with Dr Thomas Levy - Lies are Unbekoming (substack.com)

Question 2: How did the invention of the refrigerator contribute to the modern health crisis, according to the authors?

According to the authors, the invention of the refrigerator in 1876 led to a significant shift in food preservation methods. People stopped using mineral-rich sea salt or rock salt to preserve meats and other foods, which resulted in a gradual depletion of essential minerals in the diet over generations. This mineral deficiency, particularly in trace minerals, has contributed to the modern health crisis.

Question 3: What warning did Dr. Charles Northern issue in 1936 regarding the relationship between soil depletion and human health?

In 1936, Dr. Charles Northern warned that the depletion of minerals in American soil due to modern farming practices was leading to numerous human health problems. He stated that "countless human ills stem from the fact that the impoverished soil of America no longer provides plant foods with mineral elements essential to human nourishment and health."

Question 4: How do the authors explain the concept of "mineral substitution" in the body, and what are its potential consequences?

The authors explain that when the body is deficient in specific minerals, it may attempt to substitute similar-acting minerals to compensate for the deficiency. This process, called the "Thompson-Döbereiner principle of mineral substitution," can lead to imbalances and health issues. For example, if the body is deficient in calcium, it may use strontium as a substitute, which can result in abnormal bone formation and joint problems.

Question 5: What is the "Calcium Cascade," and how does it affect various aspects of human health?

The "Calcium Cascade" refers to the series of negative health consequences that can occur when there is an excess of calcium in the body. This cascade begins with calcium seeking more magnesium to maintain balance, leading to a relative magnesium deficiency. The body then suppresses adrenal function to retain magnesium, causing a continuous loss of sodium and potassium. This loss of essential minerals leads to various health issues, such as digestive problems, impaired protein synthesis, and metabolic disorders like obesity, heart disease, and type 2 diabetes.

Question 6: How do hair tissue mineral analysis (HTMA) tests help in determining an individual's mineral status, and why are they considered important by the authors?

Hair tissue mineral analysis (HTMA) tests provide a comprehensive picture of an individual's mineral status by measuring the concentrations of various minerals in a hair sample. The authors consider HTMA tests crucial because they reveal intracellular mineral levels, which can differ significantly from serum levels measured in blood tests. By identifying mineral imbalances and deficiencies through HTMA, healthcare providers can develop targeted nutritional interventions to correct these issues and improve overall health.

Question 7: What similarities do the authors highlight among the dietary habits of long-lived cultures around the world?

The authors point out that long-lived cultures, such as the Tibetans, Hunzas, Titicacans, Vilacambans, and Caucasus mountain inhabitants, share a common dietary habit: consuming large amounts of unrefined sea salt or rock salt. These salts contain a full spectrum of essential minerals in balanced proportions, contributing to the longevity and health of these populations. In contrast, the modern Western diet, which relies heavily on refined table salt, lacks these vital minerals.

Question 8: How does excess calcium in the body contribute to the development of various diseases, such as osteoporosis, osteoarthritis, and kidney stones?

Excess calcium in the body can lead to the development of several diseases:

· Osteoporosis: When calcium is in excess, it can paradoxically weaken bones by causing mineral imbalances and inhibiting the absorption of other essential bone-building minerals.

· Osteoarthritis: Excess calcium can form crystals or "gravel" in joint spaces, leading to inflammation, abnormal bone formation, and joint degeneration.

· Kidney stones: High levels of calcium in the body can contribute to the formation of calcium-based kidney stones.

· Additionally, excess calcium can deposit in soft tissues, such as arteries (causing plaque), the brain (leading to impaired function and dementia), and other organs, causing a range of health problems.

Question 9: What role do bisphosphonate drugs play in the treatment of osteoporosis, and what are their potential side effects?

Bisphosphonate drugs, such as Fosamax, Boniva, and Actonel, are commonly prescribed for the treatment of osteoporosis. These drugs work by slowing down the natural bone resorption and remodeling process, making bones denser. However, the authors caution that bisphosphonates can have serious side effects, such as causing bones to become brittle and more prone to fracture, as well as increasing the risk of osteonecrosis (death of bone tissue) in the jaw. Additionally, bisphosphonates can exacerbate mineral imbalances by inhibiting the body's ability to access its mineral stores in bones.

Osteoporosis - Lies are Unbekoming (substack.com)

Question 10: How does the "Calcium Cascade" lead to the suppression of the adrenal glands and the continuous loss of sodium and potassium from the body?

In the "Calcium Cascade," excess calcium in the body triggers a series of events that ultimately lead to the suppression of the adrenal glands and the loss of sodium and potassium. As calcium levels rise, the body seeks more magnesium to maintain balance. To retain magnesium, the adrenal glands are suppressed, which in turn causes sodium and potassium to be continuously excreted in the urine. This ongoing loss of sodium and potassium from the body's cells further exacerbates mineral imbalances and contributes to various health problems.

Question 11: What is the sodium/potassium membrane electrical potential (S/PMEP), and how does its failure affect cellular function and health?

The sodium/potassium membrane electrical potential (S/PMEP) refers to the electrical charge difference across cell membranes that is maintained by the balance of sodium and potassium ions. This electrical potential is crucial for various cellular functions, such as the transport of nutrients like glucose and amino acids into cells. When excess calcium and the resulting mineral imbalances disrupt the S/PMEP, cells become unable to efficiently absorb these essential nutrients, leading to impaired cellular function and the development of various health issues, such as insulin resistance, metabolic disorders, and even cardiovascular problems.

Question 12: How do digestive issues, such as heartburn and GERD, relate to mineral deficiencies and imbalances in the body?

Digestive issues like heartburn and gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) are often related to mineral deficiencies and imbalances, particularly a lack of sodium and potassium. These minerals are essential for the production of stomach acid (hydrochloric acid), which is necessary for proper digestion. When the body is deficient in sodium and potassium, often due to the "Calcium Cascade," it cannot produce enough stomach acid, leading to impaired digestion, heartburn, and GERD. Contrary to popular belief, these issues are more likely caused by too little stomach acid rather than too much.

Question 13: What are the consequences of poor protein digestion and amino acid deficiencies on various aspects of health, such as brain function and metabolism?

Poor protein digestion and amino acid deficiencies can have far-reaching consequences on various aspects of health. Amino acids are essential for the synthesis of neurotransmitters, such as serotonin and dopamine, which regulate mood, sleep, and cognitive function. A deficiency in these neurotransmitters can lead to depression, anxiety, insomnia, and other mental health issues. Additionally, amino acids are crucial for the production of enzymes, hormones, and other proteins involved in metabolism, growth, and repair. Inadequate amino acid levels can result in metabolic disorders, impaired immune function, and suboptimal overall health.

Question 14: How does stress affect the body's mineral balance, particularly sodium and potassium levels, and what are the potential health implications?

Stress can significantly impact the body's mineral balance, particularly sodium and potassium levels. During times of chronic stress, the adrenal glands increase the production of stress hormones, which can lead to the retention of sodium and the excretion of potassium. This imbalance can contribute to high blood pressure, digestive issues, and other stress-related health problems. Over time, chronic stress can deplete the body's mineral stores, exacerbating mineral imbalances and increasing the risk of various health issues, such as cardiovascular disease, immune dysfunction, and metabolic disorders.

Caffeine - Lies are Unbekoming (substack.com)

Question 15: What are the five types of hypothyroidism described by the authors, and how do they differ in terms of causes and treatment approaches?

The authors describe five types of hypothyroidism:

· Type 1: Caused by a failure of the thyroid gland to produce sufficient thyroid hormones. Treated with thyroid hormone replacement therapy.

· Type 2 (Thyroid Hormone Resistance): Occurs when the body produces enough thyroid hormones but is unable to utilize them effectively. Caused by an intracellular calcium/potassium imbalance. Treated by correcting mineral imbalances and using thyroid hormone replacement until the resistance resolves.

· Type 3: Autoimmune thyroid disease, such as Hashimoto's thyroiditis. May be triggered by factors like bromine exposure. Treated with low-dose cortisol, increased iodine intake, and other targeted therapies.

· Type 4 (Severe Selenium Deficiency): Rare form caused by a severe lack of selenium. Treated with selenium supplementation.

· Type 5 (Wilson's Temperature Syndrome): Characterized by an elevated reverse T3 (rT3) level. Often inadequately treated with T4 alone. Requires a combination of T4 and T3 supplementation.

Question 16: How does insulin resistance contribute to obesity and other metabolic disorders, and what role do mineral imbalances play in this process?

Insulin resistance occurs when cells become less responsive to insulin, leading to higher blood sugar levels and increased insulin production. This can contribute to obesity, as the excess glucose is often stored as fat. Mineral imbalances, particularly those involving calcium, sodium, and potassium, play a significant role in the development of insulin resistance. The "Calcium Cascade" and the resulting disruption of the sodium/potassium membrane electrical potential (S/PMEP) impair the ability of cells to absorb glucose and amino acids, further exacerbating insulin resistance and promoting fat storage. Addressing these underlying mineral imbalances is crucial for improving insulin sensitivity and managing obesity and related metabolic disorders.

Question 17: What are the symptoms and consequences of adrenal insufficiency or suppression, and how can it be addressed through dietary and lifestyle changes?

Symptoms of adrenal insufficiency or suppression include fatigue, weakness, weight loss, low blood pressure, digestive issues, and impaired immune function. Consequences can include an increased risk of infections, autoimmune disorders, and other chronic health problems. To address adrenal insufficiency, the authors recommend dietary and lifestyle changes such as increasing sodium intake (if HTMA results indicate a deficiency), consuming balanced trace minerals, managing stress through techniques like daily walking, and supporting adrenal function with targeted supplements like vitamin C, vitamin B5, and adaptogenic herbs. Identifying and correcting underlying mineral imbalances through HTMA testing is also crucial for restoring adrenal health.

Question 18: How does pregnancy affect a woman's mineral status, and what are the potential risks associated with mineral depletion during and after pregnancy?

Pregnancy places significant demands on a woman's mineral stores, as the growing fetus requires a steady supply of essential minerals for proper development. On average, a woman loses approximately 10% of her total body mineral stores to her baby during pregnancy. This mineral depletion can lead to various health risks for the mother, such as osteoporosis, postpartum depression, fatigue, and an increased likelihood of developing conditions like gestational diabetes and hypertension. Replenishing lost minerals through a balanced diet and appropriate supplementation during and after pregnancy is crucial for maintaining the health of both the mother and the child.

Question 19: What is the connection between mineral deficiencies in pregnant women and the increased risk of birth defects and developmental issues in their children?

Mineral deficiencies in pregnant women can significantly increase the risk of birth defects and developmental issues in their children. The authors draw parallels to animal husbandry, where providing livestock with mineral-rich salt has been shown to reduce birth defects by 98% and miscarriages by 70%. They argue that a similar approach in human nutrition could potentially prevent a large percentage of birth defects and developmental problems. Ensuring adequate mineral intake, particularly through balanced trace mineral supplementation before and during pregnancy, is essential for supporting the healthy development of the growing fetus and reducing the risk of these complications.

Question 20: How can mineral imbalances contribute to the development of gestational diabetes, and what strategies do the authors recommend for managing this condition?

Mineral imbalances, particularly those involving calcium, sodium, and potassium, can contribute to the development of gestational diabetes by promoting insulin resistance. The disruption of the sodium/potassium membrane electrical potential (S/PMEP) caused by these imbalances impairs the ability of cells to absorb glucose, leading to higher blood sugar levels and increased insulin production. To manage gestational diabetes, the authors recommend strategies such as maintaining a balanced mineral intake through diet and supplementation, regular monitoring of glucose and insulin levels (focusing on the glucose/insulin ratio), and the use of targeted supplements like chromium polynicotinate (ChromeMate) to improve insulin sensitivity. Addressing underlying mineral imbalances through HTMA testing is also crucial for effectively managing gestational diabetes and reducing the risk of complications for both the mother and the child.

Question 21: What role do bioidentical hormones play in maintaining women's health during menopause, and why do the authors advocate for their use over synthetic hormone replacements?

Bioidentical hormones are chemically identical to the hormones naturally produced by the human body and are derived from plant sources. They play a crucial role in maintaining women's health during menopause by helping to alleviate symptoms such as hot flashes, mood swings, and vaginal dryness, while also reducing the risk of chronic diseases like osteoporosis and cardiovascular disease. The authors advocate for the use of bioidentical hormones over synthetic hormone replacements because they are safer and more effective. Unlike synthetic hormones, which have been linked to increased risks of breast cancer, blood clots, and other adverse effects, bioidentical hormones have a more favorable safety profile and are better tolerated by most women. The authors argue that the use of balanced, physiologic doses of bioidentical hormones should replace all other forms of hormone replacement therapy for optimal menopausal health.

Hormones - Lies are Unbekoming (substack.com)

Beyond Surgery - Lies are Unbekoming (substack.com)

Question 22: How does the "Vitamin C Lie" perpetuate misconceptions about the nutrient's benefits, and what is the difference between whole-food vitamin C and ascorbic acid?

The "Vitamin C Lie" perpetuates the misconception that vitamin C is synonymous with ascorbic acid, leading people to believe that consuming high doses of isolated ascorbic acid supplements can provide the same health benefits as whole-food vitamin C. However, the authors argue that ascorbic acid is just one component of the complex vitamin C molecule and that the entire molecule is necessary for optimal health benefits. Whole-food vitamin C contains a variety of synergistic compounds, such as bioflavonoids, tyrosinase, and copper, which work together to support various bodily functions, including collagen synthesis, immune function, and cardiovascular health. In contrast, isolated ascorbic acid acts more like a drug, potentially causing imbalances and even depleting the body of the real vitamin C complex. The authors emphasize the importance of obtaining vitamin C from whole-food sources or supplements that contain the complete vitamin C complex for genuine health benefits.

Vitamin C - Lies are Unbekoming (substack.com)

Question 23: What are the potential dangers of consuming isolated or synthetic vitamin supplements, as opposed to whole-food-based vitamins?

Consuming isolated or synthetic vitamin supplements can pose several potential dangers, as opposed to whole-food-based vitamins. First, isolated vitamins lack the synergistic cofactors and balance found in whole-food sources, which can lead to imbalances and suboptimal utilization by the body. Second, synthetic vitamins may act more like drugs in the body, causing potential side effects and even depleting the body of the actual vitamin complexes they are meant to replace. Third, the bioavailability and absorption of isolated vitamins may be lower than whole-food-based vitamins, reducing their overall effectiveness. Finally, some synthetic vitamins can accumulate in the body and reach toxic levels, especially fat-soluble vitamins like A and D. The authors stress the importance of obtaining vitamins from whole-food sources or supplements that contain complete vitamin complexes to ensure optimal safety and efficacy.

Vitamin A Toxicity - Lies are Unbekoming (substack.com)

Question 24: How do monosaccharides contribute to the proper functioning of protein molecules in the body, and what are the consequences of monosaccharide deficiencies?

Monosaccharides play a crucial role in the proper functioning of protein molecules in the body by acting as recognition sites or "keys" that enable proteins to carry out their specific functions. Every protein molecule has a complex monosaccharide receptor on its biologically active end, which allows it to interact with other molecules and perform its designated role in various bodily processes, such as DNA and RNA synthesis, hormone activity, and immune function. Monosaccharide deficiencies can lead to the synthesis of abnormal proteins with dysfunctional receptors, which can accumulate and trigger autoimmune responses or allergic reactions. Specific monosaccharide deficiencies have been linked to autoimmune diseases like systemic lupus erythematosus, rheumatoid arthritis, and scleroderma. Ensuring an adequate intake of essential monosaccharides through a balanced diet and appropriate supplementation is necessary for maintaining the proper structure and function of protein molecules and preventing monosaccharide deficiency-related health issues.

Question 25: What are the seven essential steps the authors recommend for improving overall health and addressing mineral imbalances?

The authors recommend seven essential steps for improving overall health and addressing mineral imbalances:

· Drink pure water: Consume at least half your body weight in ounces of pure water daily.

· Take ionic sea salt-derived minerals: Supplement with balanced trace minerals to address deficiencies and imbalances.

· Consume whole-food vitamins: Obtain vitamins from whole-food sources or supplements that contain complete vitamin complexes.

· Ensure adequate essential fatty acid intake: Consume healthy fats from sources like raw nuts, seeds, and cold-water fatty fish.

· Eat high-quality proteins: Choose organic, grass-fed, or wild-caught animal proteins and plant-based proteins from sources like raw seeds and nuts.

· Include monosaccharide-rich foods: Consume foods that naturally contain essential monosaccharides, such as raw fruits, vegetables, and whole grains.

· Manage stress: Engage in stress-reducing activities like daily walking and practice relaxation techniques to support overall mineral balance and health.

Question 26: Why do the authors emphasize the importance of consuming unrefined sea salt and rock salt, and how do these natural sources of minerals differ from refined table salt?

The authors emphasize the importance of consuming unrefined sea salt and rock salt because these natural sources contain a balanced array of essential minerals and trace elements necessary for optimal health. Unlike refined table salt, which is composed almost entirely of sodium chloride, unrefined sea salt and rock salt provide a full spectrum of minerals in proportions that closely resemble the mineral composition of human body fluids. These minerals work synergistically to support various bodily functions, such as maintaining proper fluid balance, nerve and muscle function, and bone health. Additionally, the trace elements found in unrefined salt, such as iodine, selenium, and magnesium, play crucial roles in thyroid function, antioxidant defense, and enzymatic reactions. By consuming unrefined sea salt and rock salt instead of refined table salt, individuals can help replenish their mineral stores and maintain a healthy mineral balance.

Question 27: What role does chronic stress play in disrupting the body's mineral balance, particularly sodium and potassium levels, and how can this be managed through lifestyle changes like walking?

Chronic stress can significantly disrupt the body's mineral balance, particularly sodium and potassium levels, through its impact on adrenal gland function. During times of stress, the adrenal glands increase the production of stress hormones, such as cortisol and aldosterone, which can lead to the retention of sodium and the excretion of potassium. This imbalance can contribute to various health problems, including high blood pressure, digestive issues, and impaired immune function. Over time, chronic stress can deplete the body's mineral stores, exacerbating existing imbalances and increasing the risk of stress-related disorders.

To manage the impact of chronic stress on mineral balance, the authors recommend lifestyle changes like daily walking. Regular walking has been shown to have profound stress-reducing effects by promoting relaxation, reducing cortisol levels, and improving overall well-being. The authors suggest that walking may be more effective than other forms of exercise in managing stress because it encourages a slower pace and allows for a greater connection with nature. By incorporating daily walks into their routine, individuals can help regulate their adrenal function, reduce the impact of stress on mineral balance, and support overall health and resilience.

Question 28: How do the authors challenge the conventional medical approach to treating hypothyroidism, and what alternative strategies do they propose based on the five types of hypothyroidism they identify?

The authors challenge the conventional medical approach to treating hypothyroidism, which typically relies on blood tests (particularly TSH levels) and the use of synthetic T4 (levothyroxine) as the primary treatment. They argue that this approach fails to address the underlying causes of hypothyroidism and often results in inadequate symptom relief and suboptimal patient outcomes.

Based on the five types of hypothyroidism they identify, the authors propose alternative strategies for diagnosis and treatment:

· Type 1: Caused by a failure of the thyroid gland to produce sufficient hormones. In addition to thyroid hormone replacement, the authors suggest addressing potential underlying factors, such as iodine deficiency or selenium deficiency.

· Type 2 (Thyroid Hormone Resistance): Caused by an intracellular calcium/potassium imbalance. The authors recommend correcting mineral imbalances through diet and supplementation, as well as using thyroid hormone replacement until the resistance resolves.

· Type 3 (Autoimmune Thyroiditis): The authors suggest addressing potential triggers like bromine exposure, supplementing with iodine, and using low-dose cortisol to manage the autoimmune response.

· Type 4 (Severe Selenium Deficiency): The authors recommend selenium supplementation to correct this rare form of hypothyroidism.

· Type 5 (Wilson's Temperature Syndrome): Characterized by an elevated reverse T3 (rT3) level. The authors argue for the use of a combination of T4 and T3 supplementation, rather than T4 alone.

In all cases, the authors emphasize the importance of a comprehensive approach that includes addressing mineral imbalances (through HTMA testing), optimizing nutrition, and managing stress to effectively treat hypothyroidism and restore overall health.

Question 29: What is the "Vitamin Lie," and how does it mislead consumers about the supposed benefits of synthetic vitamin supplements?

The "Vitamin Lie" refers to the misconception that synthetic, isolated vitamin supplements can provide the same health benefits as whole-food-based vitamins. This lie misleads consumers into believing that these synthetic supplements are equivalent to or even superior to the vitamins found naturally in whole foods.

The authors argue that most vitamin supplements on the market today are not true vitamins but are instead synthetic chemical compounds that resemble only a portion of the complete vitamin complex found in nature. These isolated vitamins lack the synergistic cofactors and balance found in whole-food sources, which can lead to imbalances, suboptimal utilization by the body, and even potential toxicity.

Moreover, the bioavailability and absorption of synthetic vitamins may be lower than whole-food-based vitamins, reducing their overall effectiveness. Some synthetic vitamins may also act more like drugs in the body, causing potential side effects and even depleting the body of the actual vitamin complexes they are meant to replace.

The "Vitamin Lie" perpetuates the belief that consuming these synthetic supplements can compensate for a nutrient-poor diet, leading consumers to rely on these products rather than focusing on obtaining vitamins from whole-food sources. The authors stress the importance of educating consumers about the differences between synthetic and whole-food-based vitamins and emphasize the superiority of obtaining nutrients from a balanced, whole-food-based diet.

Question 30: How can the overemphasis on calcium supplementation, as perpetuated by the "Calcium Lie," actually contribute to the development of osteoporosis and other bone-related issues?

The overemphasis on calcium supplementation, as perpetuated by the "Calcium Lie," can actually contribute to the development of osteoporosis and other bone-related issues by creating mineral imbalances and disrupting the body's natural bone metabolism. The authors argue that bones are composed of a complex matrix of minerals, not just calcium, and that focusing solely on calcium supplementation can lead to several problems:

· Calcium excess: Overconsuming calcium supplements can lead to an accumulation of excess calcium in the body, which can paradoxically weaken bones by interfering with the absorption and utilization of other essential bone-building minerals, such as magnesium, phosphorus, and vitamin D.

· Mineral imbalances: The "Calcium Lie" disregards the importance of maintaining a proper balance among the various minerals involved in bone health. Excessive calcium intake can create imbalances in the calcium-to-magnesium ratio, which can impair bone mineralization and increase the risk of osteoporosis.

· Vitamin K2 deficiency: The overemphasis on calcium supplementation often overlooks the crucial role of vitamin K2 in directing calcium to the bones and teeth, rather than allowing it to accumulate in soft tissues like arteries and kidneys. A deficiency in vitamin K2 can contribute to poor bone health and increase the risk of calcium-related health issues.

· Disruption of natural bone remodeling: The body's natural bone remodeling process involves a balanced cycle of bone formation and resorption. Excessive calcium supplementation can disrupt this delicate balance, leading to an increased risk of osteoporosis and fractures over time.

Instead of relying on calcium supplements alone, the authors recommend a holistic approach to bone health that emphasizes obtaining a balanced array of essential minerals and vitamins through a nutrient-dense diet and targeted, whole-food-based supplementation based on individual needs as determined by HTMA testing.

Question 31: What specific supplements and dietary changes do the authors recommend for addressing mineral imbalances and deficiencies, and why do they emphasize the importance of whole-food-based nutrients?

The authors recommend several specific supplements and dietary changes for addressing mineral imbalances and deficiencies:

· Ionic sea salt-derived minerals: Supplementing with balanced trace minerals in ionic form, derived from unrefined sea salt, can help replenish mineral stores and correct imbalances. The authors emphasize the importance of using ionic minerals, as they are easily absorbed and utilized by the body.

· Whole-food-based vitamins: Obtaining vitamins from whole-food sources or supplements that contain complete vitamin complexes is crucial for ensuring optimal nutrient synergy and bioavailability. The authors caution against relying on synthetic, isolated vitamin supplements, which can create imbalances and even deplete the body of the actual vitamin complexes.

· Essential fatty acids: Consuming adequate amounts of healthy fats from sources like raw nuts, seeds, and cold-water fatty fish can support overall health and mineral balance. The authors recommend avoiding heated or processed oils and focusing on raw, unrefined sources of essential fatty acids.

· High-quality proteins: Choosing organic, grass-fed, or wild-caught animal proteins and plant-based proteins from sources like raw seeds and nuts can provide the necessary amino acids for proper mineral utilization and overall health.

· Monosaccharide-rich foods: Including foods that naturally contain essential monosaccharides, such as raw fruits, vegetables, and whole grains, can support the proper functioning of protein molecules and prevent monosaccharide deficiency-related health issues.

The authors emphasize the importance of whole-food-based nutrients because they contain the full spectrum of synergistic cofactors and balanced components that work together to support optimal health. Whole-food-based supplements are less likely to cause imbalances or adverse effects compared to isolated, synthetic nutrients. By focusing on obtaining nutrients from whole-food sources and carefully selected supplements, individuals can more effectively address mineral imbalances and deficiencies while promoting overall health and well-being.

Question 32: How do the authors challenge the conventional medical establishment's approach to nutrition and wellness, and what alternative paradigms do they propose?

The authors challenge the conventional medical establishment's approach to nutrition and wellness in several key ways:

· Overemphasis on isolated nutrients: The authors argue that the conventional approach often focuses on single nutrients, such as calcium or specific vitamins, rather than considering the complex interplay of nutrients found in whole foods. They propose a paradigm shift towards emphasizing the importance of nutrient synergy and balance, as found in whole-food-based nutrition.

· Reliance on synthetic supplements: The authors criticize the conventional medical establishment's reliance on synthetic, isolated vitamin and mineral supplements, which they argue can create imbalances and even deplete the body of the actual nutrient complexes. They advocate for a paradigm that prioritizes whole-food-based supplements and dietary sources of nutrients.

· Inadequate recognition of mineral imbalances: The authors assert that the conventional approach often fails to acknowledge the crucial role of mineral imbalances in the development of chronic diseases. They propose a paradigm that emphasizes the use of HTMA testing to identify and address individual mineral imbalances and deficiencies.

· Symptom-based treatment: The authors argue that the conventional medical establishment often focuses on treating symptoms rather than addressing the underlying causes of health issues. They propose a paradigm that seeks to identify and correct the root causes of illness, such as mineral imbalances, nutritional deficiencies, and lifestyle factors.

· Lack of a holistic approach: The authors challenge the conventional approach's tendency to compartmentalize health issues and treat them in isolation. They propose a holistic paradigm that recognizes the interconnectedness of various body systems and emphasizes the importance of addressing health concerns in a comprehensive, integrated manner.

As an alternative, the authors propose a paradigm that prioritizes whole-food-based nutrition, individualized mineral balancing through HTMA testing, and a holistic approach to health that addresses the underlying causes of illness. This paradigm emphasizes the importance of patient education, self-empowerment, and collaboration between healthcare providers and patients in achieving optimal wellness.

Question 33: What is the central message that the authors aim to convey to readers, and how do they hope this information will empower individuals to take control of their health?

The central message that the authors aim to convey to readers is that achieving optimal health requires a fundamental shift in our understanding of nutrition, mineral balance, and the role of whole-food-based nutrients in preventing and reversing chronic diseases. They argue that the conventional medical establishment's approach, which often relies on isolated nutrients, synthetic supplements, and symptom-based treatment, fails to address the root causes of illness and can even contribute to the development of health problems.

The authors hope that by exposing the "Calcium Lie," the "Vitamin Lie," and other misconceptions perpetuated by the mainstream medical establishment, they can empower individuals to take control of their health by:

· Educating themselves about the importance of whole-food-based nutrition and the role of mineral balance in maintaining optimal health.

· Seeking out healthcare providers who embrace a holistic, patient-centered approach and prioritize the use of HTMA testing to identify and address individual mineral imbalances and deficiencies.

· Making informed choices about their diet and supplement regimen, focusing on whole-food-based sources of nutrients and carefully selected, high-quality supplements that support mineral balance and overall health.

· Adopting lifestyle practices that promote mineral balance and wellness, such as stress management techniques, regular exercise, and the consumption of pure water and unrefined sea salt.

· Advocating for a paradigm shift in the way the medical establishment approaches nutrition and wellness, emphasizing the importance of prevention, patient education, and individualized, holistic care.

By providing readers with the knowledge and tools to take a proactive role in their health, the authors hope to inspire a grassroots movement towards a more natural, whole-food-based approach to nutrition and wellness. They believe that by empowering individuals to make informed choices and advocating for change within the medical establishment, we can collectively overcome the chronic disease epidemic and achieve optimal health and vitality.

Lies are Unbekoming

The Calcium Lie

By Robert Thompson and Kathleen Barnes – Unbekoming Book Summary

Interview with Dr Thomas Levy - Lies are Unbekoming (substack.com)

Could you discuss calcium's role in contributing to chronic diseases like heart disease and cancer?

The Calcium Lie

What your doctor still doesn’t know

By Robert Thompson and Kathleen Barnes

Questions & Answers

Discussion about this post