Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Bushtaxi's avatar

thank you for this, but wasn't Russell just quoting Fichte when he stated 'Education should aim at destroying free will'? and I don't think he was endorsing the statement either... His whole book was debating the potential (titular) impacts , and he goes on to discuss how dictatorships might use this and other strategies to entirely shape the character of the young...

Expand full comment
Anna Stigen's avatar

"Vile" Bertrand Russell believed that mass education served to enforce the dominant paradigms of the ruling class; he thought that this was bad, because it did not take into account the actual child, regarding the student as mere material to be manipulated and controlled. What he personally believed was that education should have a "spirit of reverence" for the child's intellectual and emotional development. The author of the article also mistakes a satirical essay lampooning the extremism of the left and right as an earnest editorial. Gross misrepresentations of another person's work is, to my mind, worse than plagiarism--at least in the latter case, the meaning is preserved. Nice presentation of Iserbyt, though--

Expand full comment
20 more comments...

No posts