Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Robert Yoho, MD's avatar

Unbekoming: you know I am your biggest fan. I submit this critique with utmost respect. I know you are a reporter here, and not the author of these ideas.

This article is filled with circumstantial data and ideas about ultrasound dangers that are loosely related but unpersuasive. I have not reviewed the AMD article. Notably:

Ultrasound is not an electromagnetic field (EMF), nor is it a microwave. Bringing these in are straw-man arguments.

Medicalization of the birth process is unfortunate, but there is no evidence of ultrasound damage.

The midwife-physician divide has nothing to do with this issue. No midwife can claim a mid-double-digit decrease in patient and maternal mortality. Physician obstetricians did this in the 1950s.

The Chinese studies were on fetuses to be aborted and showed no evidence of damage that was later evident on birth.

You showed me the Control Group Study. Given its proof that all chronic illnesses were primarily determined by vaccination status, I refuse to believe that ultrasounds are anything but window dressing on the overall autism disaster. Ditto SIDS. Articles like this one distract from the primary issue. We should be beating the drums about THAT.

Home birth gives up the double-digit mortality advantage of physician-supervised birth.

This is the same sort of “evidence” that inhabits this article, but I find it hard to believe that with all the focus on ultrasounds, the hardest evidence of harm we have is “tissue damage” reported in Chinese studies without any reported fetal outcome issue.

I could say lots more nasty things about OB-GYNs, but I will leave it at: I have little sympathy for them. Their high C-section and hysterectomy rates alone convict them as one of the most careless specialties. However, they are no match for pediatricians, dentists, oncologists, psychiatrists, or even cardiac surgeons or cardiologists.

Expand full comment
Virginia Stoner's avatar

Thanks for this info. The extreme dangers of ultrasound were also exposed in a book by Jim West some years ago, in which he reviewed a lot of little-known Chinese research on ultrasound. https://www.amazon.com/Studies-Conducted-Indicate-Prenatal-Ultrasound-ebook/dp/B00X06QDYS

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts